The most common Microsoft 365 security gaps are not missing products. They are settings nobody turned on: MFA that only covers some users, legacy sign-in methods left open, too many global admins, unchecked mail forwarding, and alerts nobody reads. Most can be fixed with licenses many businesses already pay for.
Microsoft 365 is built to be easy to start using. Securing it is a separate job, and in many small businesses nobody was ever assigned to it.
Why Default Settings Leave Room for Risk
When a business first signs up for Microsoft 365, the person who creates the account automatically becomes a Global Administrator. From there, users get added, mailboxes get moved over, and the tenant security configuration rarely gets a second look.
Microsoft does provide a baseline. Security defaults require users to register for multifactor authentication and block legacy authentication protocols. They can be switched off, though, and Microsoft says organizations with Entra ID P1 or P2 licenses are probably better served by Conditional Access, which takes deliberate setup.
The M365 Security Settings Most Often Missed
These M365 security settings are easy to overlook and worth checking first.
MFA That Does Not Cover Everyone
MFA is often turned on for some users and not others, or set up user by user years ago and never moved to a central policy. Every user and every admin account should be covered, with no leftover exceptions from the original setup.
Legacy Authentication Still Allowed
Older sign-in protocols used by some email clients and devices cannot use multifactor authentication at all. Blocking them closes a door that MFA cannot.
Too Many Global Administrators
Microsoft recommends that fewer than five people hold the Global Administrator role. Admins should also use a separate account for admin work instead of their everyday mailbox.
Mail Forwarding Nobody Has Reviewed
Attackers who get into a mailbox often set up a rule that quietly forwards messages to an outside address. Check that automatic forwarding to external addresses is blocked or limited, and review existing inbox rules.
Alerts Nobody Watches
Logging only helps if someone looks at it. Confirm audit logging is on, set alerts for risky events such as new admin role assignments, and decide who receives them.
Open Sharing in SharePoint and OneDrive
"Anyone" links let a file be opened by whoever has the link, with no sign-in required. Most businesses can limit sharing to people inside the organization or named guests and set links to expire.
Conditional Access and Identity Protection
Conditional access lets you set rules for when and how people sign in. You can require MFA for everyone, block sign-ins from countries where you do no business, or require a company-managed device before anyone opens sensitive files.
It requires Microsoft Entra ID P1, which is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium. Many businesses on Business Premium already pay for these policies and have never set them up.
Good identity protection in Microsoft 365 comes down to three things: strong sign-in requirements, very few admin accounts, and fast removal of access when someone leaves.
SMB Email Security Beyond the Spam Filter
Microsoft 365 includes spam and malware filtering, but SMB email security also depends on settings outside the inbox. Make sure your domain publishes SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records so others cannot easily send mail that looks like it came from your company.
Staff matter too. Show employees how to report suspicious messages with the built-in report button, and make sure someone reviews what gets reported.

A Practical Order for Your Review
If you are not sure where to start, follow IT security best practices that put identity first and work through the tenant in this order:
- Count your Global Administrators and remove any that are not needed
- Confirm MFA covers every user
- Block legacy authentication
- Review forwarding rules and external sharing settings
- Turn on alerts and assign someone to watch them
- Document every setting so changes can be tracked
For a deeper checklist, CISA's Secure Configuration Baselines for Microsoft 365 were developed with Microsoft. They were written for federal agencies, but they are a useful reference for any organization that wants to go further.
What to Look for in MSP Microsoft Services
A secure tenant is not a one-time project. Microsoft adds features and changes defaults, and every new hire, departure, and app connection changes the picture.
When you compare MSP Microsoft services, look for a provider that reviews tenant settings on a schedule, not only when something breaks. Globalquest Solutions' Microsoft 365 services include multifactor authentication and multiple layers of security, with options such as data loss prevention and message encryption, for a predictable monthly fee.
Paired with IT security services that analyze your network and email service for weaknesses, that puts one team in charge of your whole Microsoft 365 environment.
FAQs About Microsoft 365 Security
Are security defaults enough for a small business?
For businesses without Entra ID P1 licenses, security defaults are a solid starting point. Businesses on Business Premium or a similar plan usually get finer control from Conditional Access policies, which replace security defaults.
Doesn't Microsoft secure my tenant for me?
Microsoft secures the underlying platform, but most configuration choices belong to the customer. Who can sign in, how, and from where are settings your business or IT provider controls.
How often should Microsoft 365 settings be reviewed?
At least quarterly, and any time you add a major app, change license plans, or have an employee with admin rights leave.
Do I need Business Premium to fix these gaps?
Not for all of them. Admin cleanup, forwarding rules, sharing settings, and security defaults are available on most plans. Conditional Access policies require Entra ID P1, which Business Premium includes.
Close the Gaps in Your Microsoft 365 Tenant
Most Microsoft 365 security gaps can be closed in a few focused sessions once someone knows where to look.
Globalquest Solutions helps businesses in Buffalo and across Western New York review and secure their Microsoft 365 environments. Speak with an expert at Globalquest Solutions or call (716) 601-3524.
